do not mix Pb solder with the low temp Bismuth-based solders (also there is the different melting point issues, but the alloy that forms is awful). Joint becomes very brittle due to strong intermetallic growth and easy to break with even what I could consider moderate force. For example, with the right (or wrong) mix of solder and a decent grip, I can pull SMD aluminium polymer caps off the board with my bare hands.

I'm pretty sure remember reading a super old IBM article where they investigated this Bi/Pb mix for some temperature sensitive parts in a mainframe, and it was a disaster. Can't find the article now though 

Also from

Quote

If you are looking for more details, kindly visit lead-free hasl.

Caution must be used when using tin / bismuth alloys. It is dangerous to mix tin / bismuth with lead containing alloys. Tin, bismuth, and lead can form a very low melting combination that melts around 95 °C. This could potentially lead to solder joint failure due to natural heating of the assembly during use.
 
Tin / bismuth alloys are safe to use in combination with other lead free tin-based alloys. In some cases surface mount assemblies are made with SAC305 on the first side and tin / bismuth on the second side. The low reflow temperature for tin / bismuth minimizes intermetallic growth in the SAC305 solder joints and allows for soldering of thermally sensitive components.

Definitelymix Pb solder with the low temp Bismuth-based solders (also there is the different melting point issues, but the alloy that forms is awful). Joint becomes very brittle due to strong intermetallic growth and easy to break with even what I could consider moderate force. For example, with the right (or wrong) mix of solder and a decent grip, I can pull SMD aluminium polymer caps off the board with my bare hands.I'm pretty sure remember reading a super old IBM article where they investigated this Bi/Pb mix for some temperature sensitive parts in a mainframe, and it was a disaster. Can't find the article now thoughAlso from http://www.surfacemountprocess.com/low-temperature-lead-free-solder-paste.html

What are the Difference Between HASL and HASL Lead-free in PCB?

David Yang

·

Follow

3 min read

·

Dec 21,

For more multilayer pcb design tipsinformation, please contact us. We will provide professional answers.

--

Printed Circuit Boards (PCBs) are the backbone of electronic devices, and the choice of surface finish plays a crucial role in their performance and reliability. Among the various surface finish options available, Hot Air Solder Leveling (HASL) and its lead-free counterpart, HASL Lead-free, stand out. Understanding the differences between these two processes is essential for PCB designers and manufacturers to make informed decisions. In this article, we&#;ll delve into the distinctions, explore the reasons behind them, and examine the implications for electronic applications.

The Origins of HASL and HASL Lead-free

HASL: Tradition Meets Performance

Hot Air Solder Leveling, or HASL, is a conventional and cost-effective PCB surface finish. In this process, molten solder is applied to the copper traces, forming a thin layer that provides a solderable surface for component attachment. The excess solder is then removed using hot air, leaving a level surface.

HASL Lead-free: Meeting Environmental Standards

As environmental concerns gained prominence, the electronics industry sought alternatives to the traditional HASL method. HASL Lead-free emerged as a response, replacing the lead-based solder with a composition typically containing tin, silver, and copper. This eco-friendly alternative adheres to RoHS (Restriction of Hazardous Substances) and WEEE (Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment) directives, making it compliant with global environmental standards.

The Case for HASL Lead-free

RoHS Compliance and Environmental Impact

One of the primary motivations behind the shift to HASL Lead-free is its alignment with RoHS directives. RoHS aims to restrict the use of hazardous substances in electronic products, promoting environmental sustainability. HASL Lead-free ensures compliance with these regulations, reducing the environmental impact associated with electronic waste.

Improved Solder Joint Reliability

HASL Lead-free offers superior solder joint reliability compared to its traditional counterpart. The composition of lead-free solder mitigates concerns related to the formation of brittle intermetallic compounds, enhancing the mechanical and thermal properties of solder joints. This translates into increased durability and longevity of electronic devices.

Navigating the Decision-Making Process

Application-Specific Considerations

The choice between HASL and HASL Lead-free depends on the specific requirements of the application. While HASL remains a cost-effective option for certain applications, HASL Lead-free is favored in environments where environmental regulations, reliability, and longevity are paramount concerns.

Future Trends and Innovations

With technology advancing rapidly, the PCB industry continues to explore new surface finish options. Innovations such as Immersion Silver, ENIG (Electroless Nickel Immersion Gold), and OSP (Organic Solderability Preservatives) are gaining traction, offering unique advantages based on the specific needs of electronic designs.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the difference between HASL and HASL Lead-free in PCBs extends beyond the surface. It reflects the industry&#;s commitment to environmental responsibility, improved reliability, and adapting to the evolving landscape of electronic manufacturing. Whether choosing the time-tested HASL or the eco-friendly HASL Lead-free, understanding the nuances ensures that PCBs meet the demands of both current and future electronic applications.

If you want to learn more, please visit our website pcb surface finish comparison.